hdr call icon
schedule a consultation

Jones Act vs. Longshore Act: Which Covers Your Maritime Injury?

Rights of Injured Maritime and Offshore Workers in Corpus Christi

If you were hurt working on or near the water around Corpus Christi, one of the first questions in your case is whether you are a seaman covered by the Jones Act or a maritime worker covered by the Longshore and Harbor Workers’ Compensation Act. The answer changes what you can recover, who you can sue and how the claim is handled. The two laws do not overlap: a worker who qualifies as a seaman is excluded from Longshore Act coverage, and a Longshore worker cannot bring a Jones Act claim. The Burkett Law Firm helps injured maritime workers along the Texas coast figure out which law applies and pursue every benefit available.

Who is covered by the Jones Act?

The Jones Act protects seamen, which the courts define as workers whose duties contribute to the function or mission of a vessel and whose connection to a vessel in navigation, or a fleet of vessels, is substantial in both duration and nature. As a rough guide, courts look for a worker who spends about 30 percent or more of working time aboard a vessel. Deckhands, tankermen, engineers, cooks, captains, dredge crews and crews on supply boats and floating drilling rigs commonly qualify. Our page on Corpus Christi Jones Act claims explains the seaman test in more detail.

Who is covered by the Longshore Act?

The Longshore and Harbor Workers’ Compensation Act is a federal workers’ compensation program for maritime workers who are not seamen. Coverage generally depends on two tests:

  • Status: the worker is engaged in maritime employment, such as loading and unloading ships, shipbuilding, ship repair or shipbreaking.
  • Situs: the injury happened on navigable waters or on an adjoining area customarily used for loading, unloading, building or repairing vessels, such as a pier, wharf, dock, terminal or shipyard.

Longshoremen, dock workers, crane operators at marine terminals, shipyard welders and fitters, and many harbor workers fall under the Longshore Act. Some workers on the Outer Continental Shelf are also covered through a separate federal law that borrows Longshore Act benefits.

What benefits does each law provide?

The difference in benefits is significant.

Under the Jones Act and general maritime law, a seaman can recover:

  • Maintenance and cure, owed regardless of fault
  • Full negligence damages from the employer, including past and future lost wages, loss of earning capacity, medical costs, pain and suffering and mental anguish
  • Damages from the vessel owner for unseaworthiness

Under the Longshore Act, a covered worker receives:

  • Medical care for the work injury
  • Disability compensation, generally two-thirds of the average weekly wage, subject to limits
  • Vocational rehabilitation in some cases
  • Death benefits for qualifying survivors

Longshore benefits are paid without proving fault, but they do not include pain and suffering, and the worker generally cannot sue the employer for negligence.

Can a Longshore worker sue anyone?

Yes. Even though the employer is usually protected from suit, a Longshore worker can bring a negligence claim against a third party that caused the injury. The most important is a claim against the vessel under Section 905(b) of the Act when the vessel owner’s negligence contributed to the injury, for example by turning over a ship with hidden hazards or failing to intervene in a dangerous condition it knew about. Claims can also be brought against other contractors, equipment manufacturers and terminal operators. These third-party claims can include full damages, including pain and suffering.

What about injuries at the Port of Corpus Christi?

The Port of Corpus Christi is one of the busiest energy ports in the country, with crude oil, liquefied natural gas, refined products, grain and general cargo moving across its docks. Workers at its terminals, docks and nearby shipyards include crane and forklift operators, linehandlers, riggers, welders, pipefitters and security staff. Many of them are covered by the Longshore Act rather than the Jones Act, because they work on land adjoining navigable water rather than aboard a vessel.

That does not mean they are limited to scheduled benefits. Port injuries often involve several companies at once: the terminal operator, a stevedoring company, a vessel owner and its crew, and contractors working on the same site. When a ship’s crew, a defective gangway or a vessel’s equipment causes an injury, the injured worker may have a claim against the vessel. When another contractor’s negligence causes it, a claim may be available against that contractor under Texas or maritime law.

What about workers on offshore platforms?

Workers injured on fixed production platforms in federal waters off the Texas coast usually are not seamen, because a fixed platform is not a vessel. The Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act extends Longshore Act benefits to many of these workers and applies the law of the adjacent state, here Texas, to injury claims against third parties. Our offshore oil rig accident lawyers handle these cases.

Why do employers fight over seaman status?

Because the Jones Act exposes the employer to negligence damages and a jury trial, while the Longshore Act limits the employer’s exposure to scheduled benefits. Employers and insurers sometimes push injured workers toward the program that costs them less. Common disputes include whether a structure was a vessel, whether the vessel was in navigation, and whether the worker’s time aboard was substantial enough. The answer depends on the full history of the job, not just the day of the injury. A worker reassigned to shore duty a week before the accident may still be a seaman if most of the job was spent aboard vessels, and a worker who rode a boat on the day of the injury may not be one if that was unusual. Getting this right at the start prevents a claim from being filed under the wrong law.

What evidence decides which law applies?

  • Job descriptions, assignments and crew lists
  • Time records showing how much time was spent aboard vessels
  • Vessel logs and dispatch records
  • Payroll records and union or employment contracts
  • The nature of the structure where the injury happened
  • Prior benefit filings or forms submitted to the U.S. Department of Labor

What should you do after a maritime injury?

  1. Get medical care and describe exactly how the injury happened.
  2. Report the injury to your employer in writing as soon as possible. Longshore claims have written notice requirements, generally within 30 days.
  3. Do not sign benefit forms or settlement papers without understanding which law they fall under.
  4. Keep copies of your work schedules, pay stubs and any accident report.
  5. Talk to a maritime injury lawyer before your status is decided by the employer’s paperwork.

How long do you have to file?

Jones Act and general maritime claims generally must be filed within three years of the injury. Longshore Act claims for compensation generally must be filed within one year of the injury or the last payment of compensation, with different rules for some occupational diseases. Third-party claims under Texas law may have a two-year deadline. Because the deadlines differ, it is important to sort out status early.

Frequently asked questions

Can I receive Longshore benefits and still sue the vessel owner?

Yes. A Longshore worker can collect benefits and also bring a Section 905(b) negligence claim against the vessel, although the employer or its insurer may have a lien on part of the recovery.

I work on a barge at a dock. Am I a seaman?

It depends on the barge, whether it is in navigation and how much of your work is aboard it. Some barge workers are seamen and others are Longshore workers.

Does Texas workers’ compensation apply to maritime workers?

Usually not for seamen. Some land-based workers near the water may fall under Texas comp rather than the Longshore Act, depending on their duties and where they were hurt.

How much does it cost to hire The Burkett Law Firm?

Nothing up front. We handle maritime injury cases on contingency, so you pay no attorney fee unless we recover for you.

Talk to a Corpus Christi maritime injury lawyer

If you were hurt on a vessel, a dock or in a shipyard, call The Burkett Law Firm at 361-882-8822. We have represented injured workers on the Texas coast since 1960. Learn more about our maritime injury practice.

Schedule a Free Consultation
Categories
Categories
Archives
Archives
It's Not Just A Case
It's Your Life

Since 1960, our Corpus Christi attorneys at The Burkett Law Firm have been dedicated to helping
injured people, grieving families, and other individuals obtain justice and compensation.